My favorite character in GOT is Samwell Tarly, the rotund, supposedly cowardly scholar turned unlikely defender of Castle Black. Though initially introduced as a craven weakling, his intellect, growing bravery, and purity of heart are so rewarding to observe as they unfold over the show’s eight seasons. Played by John Bradley—a drama school graduate who landed the part at his very first professional audition—his was a case of perfect casting at HBO. He was made for this role.
Reflecting on this to Conan O’Brien, Bradley revealed that he had always been highly weight conscious and had long struggled with his self-image. What shocked him in retrospect was that while he was lying awake wishing he could be different, the producers were looking for him—for exactly him, as he was, and no one else.
Here’s another example that’s close to my heart. No kid who grew up in the ’80s was unaware of the B-52s. They were a wild, frenetic rock and roll band who managed to pull off a bizarre mashup of sci-fi kitsch and ’50s-style riffs and hairdos. Fronting this auditory circus was Fred Schneider, perhaps the least likely lead singer in music history. “I can’t sing,” he once admitted. “I sort of recite. I can carry a tune about a foot.” And so he did—speak-yelling his quirky lyrics or simply banging a tambourine while the much more vocally accomplished ladies of the group ran the show.
And yet, he was perfect. No one else could give the band its energy and character as he did. A “better” singer would have upset the delicate balance that made them stars. It turns out that the very thing that looked like a limitation was the thing itself.
The trouble is that we rarely know in advance which of our peculiarities will turn out to be indispensable. And the world around us isn’t particularly interested in waiting to find out.
I doubt there’s any of us who doesn’t have some desire to “delete” a part of ourselves. Though many of us pay lip service to things like originality and freedom of thought and expression, when actually implemented, those traits can leave you feeling ignored or antagonized or lonely. It’s subtle, but our chosen milieu tends to sand down the edges that don’t quite fit. We tend to appreciate the predictable and want our friends and families to function within structures we understand, hold views sanctioned by the group, and not try to break the pattern too much.
Even our praise tends to flow toward the ones who fit the approved mold—who look and act the way we already expect—rather than the ones who break it. The soul knows what it needs to be, but the pathway often seems barricaded.
Now, I don’t mean to imply that everything we’re ashamed of is secretly a virtue. People who have an uncontrollable urge to own things without paying for them should not be celebrated for following their dreams, and someone whose first instinct is to belittle the people around him has something worth being ashamed of. Some forms of shame reflect a healthy and functional conscience. But there’s a difference between a trait and a transgression. What (and how) you are can be reframed and re-seen in profound ways. The jagged edge of your personality or skill set just might slide right into a particular receptacle. And even if it doesn’t, the pursuit itself can be good for the soul.
There’s an old Danny Thomas Show episode that somehow survived in the syndicated shows file in my TV-soaked brain. The great Tony Bennett plays Danny’s cousin, a budding young singer, and Danny himself is a nightclub performer. Tony’s father wants the boy to give up the false hope of a vocal career and join him in the family dry goods business, so he asks Danny to deliver the bad news. Danny agrees, but only as a test. He tells Tony that he doesn’t have it and won’t make it in New York. Tony refuses to back down, insisting that he simply has to sing. Upon hearing that, Danny relents and gives him a gig at the club, realizing that his cousin’s soul was born for this.
And that’s the indicator. Is there something that you are so drawn to that you simply can’t ignore it? Does the fact that you have relatively little chance of “making it” in that arena not disqualify it at all? Is it something that feels healthy and productive and good? Maybe this is a message from your essence. Could it be that a long-ignored channel in your heart has grown calcified and is exerting itself to be heard and noticed?
After all, the point isn’t necessarily to become the next John Bradley or Fred Schneider. Perhaps undamming that flow, sans accolades, would bring untold joy to an atrophied part of the true you. And perhaps that would be worth doing even if nobody else ever noticed.
John Bradley and Fred Schneider were lucky. They followed their hearts and hit it big. But there are different kinds of hits, and the most important of them has an audience of one.




